JEB DUNNUCK 94 POINTS - "Another blended wine like the Chardonnay Granitiers, the 2024 Pinot Noir Montanita De Oro is a celebration of the best mountain sites in Monterey, the 51% majority from Pelio, some Michaud, and the rest from Double LL, each at mid-elevation in different AVAs, including the soon-to-be designated Carmel Coast. Harvested, native-fermented (60% whole cluster), and aged separately, Smith blends them together in the spring to age under a year in new, second-fill, and neutral French oak. The texture is creamy smooth, with a medium-bodied wealth of crisp red fruit and dried herb. Drink now through 2034."
ANTONIO GALLONI'S VINOUS MEDIA 92 POINTS - "The 2024 Pinot Noir Montañita de Oro is a blend of Pelio (Carmel Coast), Michaud (Chalone) and Double L (SLH). It deftly combines delicacy, textural intrigue and fruit concentration. Pomegranate, orange peel, white pepper and new leather settle across the palate with velvety elegance in a mid-weight frame. The 60% whole clusters are perfectly integrated. A long, floral finish wraps things up in style. "
ANTONIO GALLONI'S VINOUS MEDIA 92 POINTS - "The 2024 Pinot Noir Montañita de Oro is a blend of Pelio (Carmel Coast), Michaud (Chalone) and Double L (SLH). It deftly combines delicacy, textural intrigue and fruit concentration. Pomegranate, orange peel, white pepper and new leather settle across the palate with velvety elegance in a mid-weight frame. The 60% whole clusters are perfectly integrated. A long, floral finish wraps things up in style. "
